Innovative Research Publication

Loading

Guidelines for Reviewers
  • Maintain confidentiality of the manuscript and review process at all times.
  • Do not use any information obtained during peer review for personal gain or to benefit others.
  • Ensure reviews are free from bias related to the author's nationality, religion, political views, or commercial interests.
  • Provide reviews that are objective, fair, and constructive.
  • Accept review assignments only if they can complete them within the agreed timeframe; if a delay is unavoidable, inform the journal promptly to request an extension.
  • Be willing to review revised versions of a manuscript they have previously reviewed, as changes may have been made since the initial submission.
  • Immediately notify the journal of any ethical concerns, such as plagiarism or simultaneous submissions, but maintain confidentiality and avoid further investigation unless requested by the editorial team.
  • Refrain from contacting the authors directly without the journal’s explicit permission.
  • Support critical feedback with clear reasoning and relevant references, particularly when claiming prior publication or duplication.
  • Avoid imposing personal writing preferences if the manuscript is clear and sound; instead, focus on suggestions that improve clarity and quality.
  • Cooperate with the journal in reviewing revised submissions when possible.